The FBI claims that their fingerprint database (IAFIS) is the "largest biometric database in the world," containing records for over a hundred million people. But that's nothing compared to the agency's plans for Next Generation Identification (NGI), a massive, billion-dollar upgrade that will hold iris scans, photos searchable with face recognition technology, palm prints, and measures of gait and voice recordings alongside records of fingerprints, scars, and tattoos.
Ambitions for the final product are candidly spelled out in an agency report: "The FBI recognizes a need to collect as much biometric data as possible within information technology systems, and to make this information accessible to all levels of law enforcement, including International agencies." (A stack of documents related to NGI was obtained by the Center for Constitutional Rights and others after a FOIA lawsuit.)
It'll be "Bigger -- Better -- Faster," the FBI brags on their Web site. Unsurprisingly, civil libertarians have concerns about the privacy ramifications of a bigger, better, faster way to track Americans using their body parts.
"NGI will expand the type and breadth of information FBI keeps on all of us," says Sunita Patel of the Center for Constitutional Rights. "There should be a balance between gathering information for law enforcement, and gathering information for its own sake."
Here are 5 things you should probably know about NGI:
1. Face Recognition
This month, the FBI is giving police departments in 4 states access to face recognition technology that lets them search the agency's mugshot database with only an image of a face. Police can repay the favor by feeding the FBI mugshots they collect from local arrests, bulking up the agency's database with images of more and more people.
The face recognition pilot program is supposed to expand to police departments across the country by 2014. When it's fully operational, the FBI expects its database to contain as many records of faces as there are fingerprints in the current database -- about 70 million, reports Nextgov.com. The agency's optimism seems warranted. If most local police departments are agreeable about information-sharing NGI can vacuum up images from all over the country.
The problem with that, civil libertarians point out, is that anyone's picture can end up in the database, regardless of whether or not they've committed a crime. Mug shots get snapped when people are arrested, and unlike a fingerprint -- which requires either arrest or consent to a background check -- a face could potentially be captured and fed into a database from anywhere.
"Anybody walking around could potentially be entered," Jennifer Lynch, a staff attorney at the Electronic Frontier Foundation, tells AlterNet. "Just the fact that those images can be taken surreptitiously raises concerns. If someone takes your fingerprints, you know. But in the face recognition context, it's possible for law enforcement to collect that data without knowledge." The millions of private and public security cameras all over the country would certainly provide a fruitful source for images, Lynch points out.
Going out in public naturally entails the risk that someone will see what you're doing or take your picture. Law enforcement officials angling for looser surveillance rules often deploy the argument that what people do in public is inherently not private. (It's also been used in recent debates over whether it's legal for police to put a GPS tracking device on someone's car without a warrant.) But privacy advocates counter that modern surveillance technology goes so far beyond the human eye, which obviously has neither the capacity to track someone's location for days (GPS) or store their image in a database (video surveillance, face recognition) that traditional distinctions between public and private don't really apply.
An agency powerpoint presented at a 2011 biometrics conference outlines some of the sophisticated technology in the FBI's face recognition initiatives. There's software that distinguishes between twins; 3-D face capture that expands way beyond frontal, two-dimensional mugshots; face-aging software; and automated face detection in video. The report also says agencies can ID individuals in "public datasets," which privacy advocates worry could potentially include social media like Facebook.
Meanwhile, existing laws are rarely up to speed with galloping technological advances in surveillance, say privacy advocates. At this point, "You just have to rely on law enforcement to do the right thing," Lynch says.
2. Iris Scans
Iris-scanning technology is the centerpiece of the second-to-last stage in the roll-out of NGI (scheduled for sometime before 2014). Iris scans offer up several advantages to law enforcement, both in terms of identifying people and fattening up databases.
The pattern of an iris is so unique it can distinguish twins, and it allegedly stays the same throughout a person's life. Like facial recognition, iris scans cut out the part where someone has to be arrested or convicted of a crime for law enforcement to grab a record of their biometric data.
"This capability has the potential to benefit law enforcement by requiring less interaction with subjects and will allow quicker acquisition," reads a CJIS report to the White House Domestic Policy Council.
In fact, being in the same place as a police officer equipped with a mobile iris-scanning device is all it takes. Last fall, police departments across the country got access to the MORIS device, a contraption attached to an iPhone that lets police collect digital fingerprints, run face recognition and take iris scans. (Over the summer, the FBI also starting passing out mobile devices to local law enforcement that lets them collect fingerprints digitally at the scene, according to Government Computer News.)
3. Rap-Back System
A lot of the action in the FBI's fingerprint database is in background checks for job applicants applying to industries that vet for criminal history, like taking care of the elderly or children, hospital work, and strangely, being a horse jockey in Michigan. As Cari Athens, writing for the Michigan Telecommunications and Law Review points out, if a job applicant checks out, the FBI either destroys the prints or returns them to the employer. But that's no fun if the goal is to collect vast amounts of biometric data!
Through the "Rap-Back" system, the FBI will offer employers another option: the agency is willing to keep the fingerprints in order to alert the employer if their new hire has run-ins with the law at any point in the future.
"The Rap-Back Service will provide authorized users the capability to receive notification of criminal and, in limited cases, civil activity of enrolled individuals that occurs after the initial processing and retention of criminal or civil fingerprint transactions," reads the FBI site.
4. Data Sharing Between Agencies
The roll-out of NGI advances another goal: breaking down barriers between databases operated by different agencies. One of the directives of the billion-dollar project is to grease information swapping between the Department of Homeland Security, the State Department, the Department of Justice, and the Department of Defense. The DOJ and DHS have worked toward "interoperatibility" between their databases for years. In 2009, the Department of Defense and DOJ also signed on to an agreement to share biometric information.
All of these agencies have been busy ramping up their collection of data. The Department of Defense's ABIS database has archived fingerprints, images of faces, iris scans, and palm prints in Iraq and Afghanistan and have started collecting voice recordings. They claim to have 5.1 million records, with 49 percent coming from Iraq, but efforts in Afghanistan are ramping up, according to a DoD powerpoint. (Biometric information gathered in Iraq will not be relinquished with our pull-out, as Spencer Ackerman reported.) The Department of Homeland Security biometric database (IDENT) grabs the fingerprints and a photo (searchable with facial recognition) of visitors to the US through a program called US-Visit. Through the Secure-Communities program, meant to reveal the immigration status of people booked in local jails, (more on that below) both IDENT and the FBI collected biometric information from local law enforcement.
A DHS powerpoint about Secure Communities promises that "Under NGI, law enforcement agencies will have the option to search multiple repositories." FBI reports detail how NGI will promote smoother swapping of more and more detailed biometric information: "NGI will increase information processing and sharing needs of the more than 18,000 local, state, federal, and international agencies who are our customers." It's not clear which international agencies will be able to tap into NGI.
The advantages of collaboration are clear, but it's not without some potentially nasty consequences. When that information includes private identifying data, like the unique pattern of an iris, fingerprint or face , civil liberties advocates see likely privacy breaches.
"With more people having access to data, you don't know where data is going, who's using it against you." says EFF's Lynch. "Particularly when you're talking about surreptitious collection like facial recognition, the government has the ability to track you wherever you go. Data sharing between agencies presents the possibility for constant surveillance."
Sunita Patel points out that cases of mistaken identity can be infinitely complicated when the information flows through multiple government agencies. If you're mistakenly flagged by one agency, she says, how would you go about scrubbing the false record whenever your fingerprint or Iris scan gets pinged by a different one?
5. NGI and Secure Communities (S-Comm)
One recent test run in interagency data-sharing has not gone particularly well: Secure Communities, a DHS program that lets local law enforcement officials run the fingerprints of people booked in jails against the IDENT database to check their immigration status and tip off ICE to undocumented immigrants.
Like many policies targeting America's immigrant population, Secure Communities (S-Comm) -- pitched as protection against violent criminals -- devolved into dragnets and mass deportations, with people getting dragged in for minor offenses like missing business permits and even for reporting crimes. In one incident a woman called the police about a domestic violence incident, only to be ensnared in deportation proceedings herself. As Marie Diamond points out in Think Progress, DHS's immigration databases have so many errors that the program "routinely flags citizens as undocumented immigrants."
To complicate matters, activists at the Center for Constitutional Rights argue that the documents they obtained after an FOIA request and lawsuit show that the FBI saw the program as a great opportunity to start beefing up NGI. The FBI then pushed reluctant local police departments to participate in the program, even though many were wary of S-Comm.
An CJIS/FBI guide instructing officials how to pitch S-Comm to local law enforcement explains that, "Ultimately, LEA participation is inevitable because SC is simply the first of a number of biometric interoperatability systems being brought online by the FBI/CJIS 'Next Generation Identification' initiative."
The document lays out strategies for dealing with resistant police departments, including, "Deploy to as many places in the surrounding locale, creating a 'ring of interoperatability' around the resistant site."
"It's a way of operationalizing wide-sweeping intelligence gathering," Sunita Patel of CCR tells AlterNet.
What could possibly go wrong?
Advancements in the collection of biometric data are double-edged: there's the threat of a massive government surveillance infrastructure working too well -- e.g., surveillance state -- and there are concerns about its weaknesses, especially in keeping data secure.
A breach of a sophisticated, multi-modal biometric database makes for a nightmarish scenario because the whole point of biometric data is that it offers unique ways to ID people, so there's no easy fix -- like a password change -- for compromised biometric data. Pointing to the dangers of identify theft of biometric data, Patel observes that, "Unlike a password, the algorithm of an iris can't be changed."
Source
BULLION
-
Ignore Polling – Democrats are in the ‘Pull the Goalie’ Phase - from The Conservative Treehouse: There is that moment in the final minutes of the hockey game’s third period, when the score is 3-2 and the coach of the lo...1 hour ago
-
7 Reasons Silver Has Been Valued for 6000+ years | BullionStar Nuggets: The Silver Story Pt 1 - In part 1 of The Silver Story, join us as we explore 7 reasons why silver has been a valued precious metal for over 6000 years.2 hours ago
-
Ed Steer: Gold manipulation -- the 'London bias,' 1970-2024 - 10:10a ET Monday, November 4, 2024 Dear Friend of GATA and Gold: GATA board member Ed Steer, publisher of *Ed Steer's Gold and Silver Digest*, today upd...3 hours ago
-
-
104 Hours - By TF 36 Comments | 4 Likes OK, well, here we go. The new week begins today but where and how it ends by Friday is anybody's guess. So you know what tha...3 hours ago
-
-
LEFT Planning Major Uprising if Trump Wins to Force Him To Call Out National Guard - This was the riot when Trump won in 2016. There is even concern that they might try to assassinate Trump if he wins. He better keep some private bodyguar...13 hours ago
-
-
WORLD’S LARGEST GOLD MINER’S COST TOPS $2,000: Newmont’s Q3 2024 Total Cost Hits New High - I was quite surprised to find out that the World's Largest Gold Mining Company's total cost surpassed $2,000 this quarter. Thus, it was no secret why Newm...1 day ago
-
-
Gold Is on the Ballot - This post Gold Is on the Ballot appeared first on Daily Reckoning. Kamala would be bullish for gold but bearish for the U.S. The post Gold Is on the Ball...2 days ago
-
Record-Breaking $506,250 for 1975 No S Proof Dime at GreatCollections - Over 200 bids were received for the most famous modern U.S. coin rarity at GreatCollections. The 1975 No S Proof Dime, released in error without the "S" ...3 days ago
-
#Economy & #Stocks Review - E&S Review Much of today's economic data, time series officially collected and produced, are highly unreliable. Statisticians employ well-documented tech...3 days ago
-
Exploration Co. Seeks Possible Large Copper System in BC - Vancouver-based minerals explorer Prosper Gold Corp. (TSVX: PGF; OTCQB: PGXFF) is focused on its district-scale Cyprus copper-gold project in north-central...3 days ago
-
Housing Market Update – DR Horton Is Down 13% - The following is an excerpt from the latest isssue of my short sellers’ newsletter. To learn more about this, follow this link: Short Sellers Journal NOTE:...6 days ago
-
Live Casino Online, Preparation Before Starting Official Betting - goldsilverworlds.com – The world of gaming has evolved dramatically, and one of the most exciting developments is the rise of live casinos online. In Ind...1 week ago
-
The Dollar, Gold and Stocks! - *Market Pendulum is pleased to announce that Sven Tövik from Sweden, is doing Sector analysis on all 11 major market sectors on a regular basis for his...1 week ago
-
The Path to the One Million Dollar Gold Bar - The One Million Dollar Gold Bar This year, the spot price of gold hit a monumental record for the first time in history: $2,500 per troy ounce of the boo...3 weeks ago
-
Gold pushing toward $3K - The precious metals of Gold and Silver saw net September gains of +$131.80 (5.2%) to $2659.40, and +$2.32 (7.9%) to $31.46 respectively. Gold, monthly1b...4 weeks ago
-
Desain Bentuk Rumah Adat China dan Penjelasannya - Rumah Adat China. Desain Bentuk Rumah Adat China dan Penjelasannya – Sudah kita ketahui bersama bahwa Indonesia merupakan Negara yang kaya akan warisan bud...3 months ago
-
Daily Gold Market Report - Central Banks Drive Gold Towards $3000/Oz Amid Rising Geopolitical and Economic Concerns (USAGOLD – 6/21/2024) Gold and silver prices are lower in early ...4 months ago
-
The Debtors and the Savers 2024 - One of the curious things about political opinions is how often the same people line up on opposite sides of different issues. The issues themselves may ha...5 months ago
-
It Isn't Just Silver - A couple articles back, I laid out the "still bullish" case on silver, and one of them being that6 months ago
-
-
How to Get Yourself Out of a Payday Loan Debt Cycle? - Payday loans have become a prevalent financial resource for millions of Americans facing short-term cash shortages. While initially marketed as a solution ...1 year ago
-
Silver-prices.net To Close, Future Content To Be Posted On Seeking Alpha - *We wish to inform you that we intend to close this website in the next few months or so and also offer you an alternative, which is free to you, as we w...1 year ago
-
Artificial Intelligence: Pandoras Box has been Opened - In 2022, I dedicated time to understanding the advancements of Artificial Intelligence and trying to get a handle on the societal impact. In the last 12...1 year ago
-
The Last Post of Silver Doctors – Thank You For Your Support! - For over ten years, SilverDoctors.com has been serving the community in providing free commentary and analysis of the precious metal markets. When we first...1 year ago
-
What if Deutsche Bank Derivatives Bubble suddenly Implodes into a Financial Black Hole https://youtu.be/-MHQENdSK2k - What if Deutsche Bank Derivatives Bubble suddenly Implodes into a Financial Black Hole https://youtu.be/-MHQENdSK2k Deutsche Bank Derivatives Bubble sudden...2 years ago
-
What if Deutsche Bank Derivatives Bubble suddenly Implodes into a Financial Black Hole https://youtu.be/-MHQENdSK2k - What if Deutsche Bank Derivatives Bubble suddenly Implodes into a Financial Black Hole https://youtu.be/-MHQENdSK2k Deutsche Bank Derivatives Bubble sudden...2 years ago
-
Pork Bellies are Gone, But Stores Still Have Bacon - Great and Wonderful Tuesday Morning Folks, The tamp continues, sort of, with Gold now up 20 cents at $1,675.40 after dipping to $1,667.50 with the hig...2 years ago
-
Rivian Laying Off Approximately 840 Employees - Rivian Laying Off Approximately 840 Employees By John Gallagher of FreightWaves Electric vehicle startup Rivian is laying off 6% of its 14,000-employee wor...2 years ago
-
SILVER and the Collapse of the Global Financial System With David Morgan - In our current economic environment, the fragility of the FIAT currency at the heart of the global financial system is beginning to show. Precious metal...2 years ago
-
Gold ETF Holdings Surge in 2022 - The SPDR Gold Shares Trust (GLD) continues to power higher in 2022 with a year-to-date gain of 7.5%. The value of gold holdings of the GLD from the begi...2 years ago
-
Gold rallies but can’t clear key price level - *Precious metal prices rallied in October as inflation fears rose to the top of the risk factors investors are watching. Silver was the standout, rising by...3 years ago
-
Ron Paul: Guess Who's The Taliban's Biggest Weapons Supplier? - The lightening-fast Taliban takeover of Afghanistan has left billions of dollars of US weapons scattered around the country for the taking. And this does...3 years ago
-
The problem with climate change politics - Western economies have moved on from free markets to the point where they hardly exist in the true meaning of the phrase. Yet the state continually claims ...3 years ago
-
👉How to Invest in Silver with Silver Expert John Lee The Silver Elephant !! - 👉How to Invest in Silver with Silver Expert John Lee The Silver Elephant !! 👉How to Invest in Silver with Silver Expert John Lee The Silver Elephant !! J...3 years ago
-
👉How to Invest in Silver with Silver Expert John Lee The Silver Elephant !! - 👉How to Invest in Silver with Silver Expert John Lee The Silver Elephant !! 👉How to Invest in Silver with Silver Expert John Lee The Silver Elephant !! J...3 years ago
-
Operational Update - The last five days have seen a huge increase in silver demand from our customers and increases in premiums from manufacturers and suppliers as global dem...3 years ago
-
The Ecstasy and The Agony of Market Bubbles - Miles Franklin sponsored this article by Gary Christenson. The opinions are his and are not investment advice. At a glance: Tesla stock, Bitcoin, and other...3 years ago
-
Latest releases from Perth mint - Starring Michael J. fox,* Back to the Future* follows the adventures of high school student Marty McFly as he travels 30 years back in time to 1955, put...3 years ago
-
Global Demand Continues to Threaten U.S. Oil Exports - In 2019, the United States imported about 6.8 million barrels per day (bpd) of crude oil and exported about 3... The post Global Demand Continues to Thre...4 years ago
-
Webinar for Beginners to Gold - If you are new to gold the webinar below I recorded yesterday will be useful. The main presentation goes for about 50 minutes and covers - The Ration...4 years ago
-
Gold and Silver Are Just Getting Started - The U.S. Mint made an unusual request last week. In a press release dated July 23, the bureau literally begged Americans to start putting coins back into c...4 years ago
-
Gold Makes Record High and Targets $6,000 in New Bull Cycle - [image: gold price prediction 2020]The gold price made a new all-time nominal high today at $1,945 per ounce. This move should not come as a surprise to an...4 years ago
-
Gold Prices Set to Break The All-Time High Record of $2000/oz - Gold Prices Set to Break The All-Time High Record of $2000/oz Gold may be a barbarous relic, but we live in barbarous times. Gold prices s...4 years ago
-
Trap Cleaning Service – Clean Traps With Houston Businesses - Every year, thousands of people visit the Houston business district to do some cleaning, but many Houston-area business owners are embarrassed by their gre...4 years ago
-
ファイザー製薬バイアグラのシルデナフィルでED改善 - EDになると、若い頃のような性行為が出来なくなるので、パートナーに嫌われるのではないかと悩んでいる男性は少なくありません。 スーパーやドラッグストアに行けば精力剤が買えますが、それを試しても効果がなかった場合は、ファイザー製薬が製造しているバイアグラを使うことをおすすめします。 バイアグラの有効成分のシル...4 years ago
-
Silver Is Ensured A Prosperous 2020 Thanks To The Fed - Snippet: In my previous article, I’ve written about how important US dollar movements are for future Silver prices. The chances of a significant Silver r...4 years ago
-
20 Months, 2 Weeks (Addendum) - Bullion... who? It has been nearly 2 years (20 month, 2 weeks) since my last post on this site (Fin). A short time after writing that post I cleaned up the...4 years ago
-
The Covid-19 Dominoes Fall: The World Is Insolvent - To understand why the financial dominoes toppled by the Covid-19 pandemic lead to global insolvency, let’s start with a household example. The point of thi...4 years ago
-
Tips on Starting & Building Your Bullion Portfolio - Investing in the precious metals market might feel harrowing at first, as the options available to you are great, offering innumerable valuable products th...5 years ago
-
DAVID MORGAN: THE COMING ENERGY BOOM - We just posted DAVID MORGAN: THE COMING ENERGY BOOM. Watch this video to listen DAVID MORGAN: THE COMING ENERGY BOOM. Let My Passion Create Your Wealth. I’...5 years ago
-
-
China’s Secret Gold Supplier Is Singapore - Singapore has been a major gold supplier to China since 2013, which was previously not publicly known. According to Statlink, Singapore net exported 102 ...6 years ago
-
Drama Korea Laughter in Waikiki Subtitle Indonesia (All 8 Episode) - Download Laughter in Waikiki Subtitle Indonesia *Drama Korea Laughter in Waikiki Subtitle Indonesia (All 8 Episode)* – Hallo kawan para pecinta *dram...6 years ago
-
34 minute Free Crypto Trading Course - 34 minute Free Crypto Trading Course CONTENT DISCLAIMER: I am not a financial advisor nor do I have a CMT certificate or anything of the like. Any decisi...6 years ago
-
The Year of the Dog Begins and Gold Gains 3% On the Week - The Year of the Dog Begins and Gold Gains 3% On the Week The Chinese New Year, also known as the Spring Festival, begins today and formally initiates the...6 years ago
-
Crypto Update 2/5/18 World Ponzi - Crypto Update 2/5/18 World Ponzi To get these updates immediately, you can become a member at http://brotherjohnf.biz/plans/subscriptions https://www.wor...6 years ago
-
Cryptocurrency ‘Bloodbath’ Takes Bitcoin Below $10,000, Is the Crypto Revolution Over? - Bitcoin, the number one cryptocurrency, is down by 20.47% in the last 24-hour period, according to CoinMarketCap. The flagship cryptocurrency is now trad...6 years ago
-
10 Ways America Is Falling Behind - zerohedge.com / by Shane Savitsky via Axios.com / 12/31/2017 If 2017 has seemed to you like a long and terrible year filled with bad news, then here’s s...6 years ago
-
-
Fed Rate Hikes, Fiscal v. Monetary Policy Why Again the Case for Gold? - What again is the case for gold? Real, heavy, in-your-hand gold? It is an anchor to the time before the Good Ship Lollypop set sail on these uncharted waters.7 years ago
-
USDollar index ahead of FED meeting - Greetings traders! 2 scenarios ahead of FED meeting for US dollar index. Trade smart, trade safe!7 years ago
-
-
IMPORTANT ANNOUNCEMENT - AS OF NOVEMBER 20,2016 TRADER DAN HAS NO CONNECTION TO WWW.TRADERDAN.COM. I AM NO LONGER PROVIDING ANY OF MY WORK CONTENT THERE. ALL OF MY WORK CAN BE FOUN...7 years ago
-
Gold Unleashed by Fed - Gold's next major upleg was likely unleashed by a very-dovish FOMC this week, which now has its hands tied on hiking rates or being hawkish due to the US e...8 years ago
-
Gold progressively matters less and less the closer we get to the biggest currency crisis in modern times. - https://www.conservativereview.com/commentary/2016/09/is-the-treasurys-proposed-ban-of-gold-jewelry-a-sign-of-things-to-come “The U.S. Treasury is proposing ...8 years ago
-
Brexit post-mortem - It is a month after Britain’s surprise vote to leave the EU. A new Conservative Prime Minister and Chancellor are in place, both David Cameron and George ...8 years ago
-
This Day in MV History: Precious Metals - These articles were published on Minyanville.com on 26th April in History. Checkout how time flies enjoy reading!Despite "Divorce Rate Indicator" Stock Cha...8 years ago
-
House Prices in New Zealand v Gold, August 2015 - *We no longer have any affiliation with Anglo Far-East Corporation. *9 years ago
-
What is a Bitcoin Worth? It Might Depend on the Price of Gold - What is a bitcoin worth? The answer may rest with the price of gold as both currencies compete to be the preferred investment during economic instability.9 years ago
-
Gold at $64,000—Bloomberg’s ‘China Gold Price’ - "JPMorgan et al, which certainly includes the BIS, have an iron grip on prices" ¤ Yesterday In Gold & Silver The gold price traded flat until it develop...9 years ago
-
Gold Market Sentiment Model – How it works - I had a question the other day asking “Does term “sudden” in your chart relevant to second derivative? In any … Continue reading →9 years ago
-
Why Cash Is King - In investing, the hardest thing to do is nothing. There is always the hot new stock or sector that demands our attention. In investing as in life, the ha...9 years ago
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment